To tell whether an entry stays at the surface or reaches the pedagogical or critical level. Use it when re-reading your entries (or when setting the reflection-level column in the table): the point is not to "grade" yourself, but to notice where you tend to stop — and push one level further.

Level Descriptor Observable indicators
Surface Describes what happened and judges the immediate result, without explaining why or connecting to pedagogical principles. Descriptive verbs predominate; no argued "because"; no alternatives mentioned.
Pedagogical Explains what happened by drawing on a specific pedagogical principle or criterion. A well-founded causal connector referring to an identifiable principle or methodological strategy.
Critical Questions one's own assumptions, weighs ethical or equity implications, and proposes a concrete alternative. An explicit personal assumption; who the decision benefits/harms; a concrete, verifiable change in "Reconstruct".

The level is assigned to the entry as a whole (the one that predominates). In a mixed entry, record the predominant level and note which fields fall above or below it. The critical level requires an explicit personal assumption and who the decision benefits or harms; Reconstruct goes with it, but is not enough on its own. The AI's estimate is indicative, has no academic effect, and the final judgement is yours.

Source: adapted from Larrivee, B. (2008). Development of a tool to assess teachers' level of reflective practice. Reflective Practice, 9(3), 341-360.